Follow by Email

Wednesday, October 17, 2018

Full remarks: De Mistura steps down




17 October 2018
Señor Presidente, Embajador Lorenti, [Sacha Lorenti, Bolivia],
Dear Friends, Members of the Council:
1.      When I briefed you last month, I said that we were approaching a moment of truth in the effort to convene a UN-facilitated, Syrian-led, Syrian-owned constitutional committee. The constitutional committee is the main item which is at the moment operationally left about how to implement [resolution] 2254. Everything else is still there on the table but that one [element] is the most important one at the moment. A credible and balanced committee could be the cornerstone of an inclusive political process for Syrians towards implementing Security Council resolution 2254 – the only one we have.
2.      Yesterday, I consulted the Secretary-General, Antonio Guterres, and received his very clear instructions regarding our accelerated efforts to convene a credible and balanced constitutional committee – the only kind that the UN Secretariat would be willing to convene and the only one it would be willing to be associated with. I will come to those instructions later.
3.      First, let’s be a little bit precise about where we are.
4.      As I told you last month, some things are quite clear. The Government list and the Opposition list of 50 names each for a constitutional committee are not in question. 
5.      But questions continue to be raised, mainly by the Syrian Government, over the composition of the Middle Third list of 50 names. So, let me recall how we did arrive at the Middle Third list that is now on the table, and indeed has already been further revised, more than once, and updated in a new list.
6.      The Sochi Final Statement spoke of the need to include, I quote: “Syrian experts, civil society, independents, tribal leaders and women” (unquote), with (quote) “adequate representation of Syria’s ethnic and religious components” (unquote). The Sochi final statement made clear that it was via the Geneva process, and the facilitation of the Special Envoy, that the final selection would be made.
7.      Actually, in truth, it went even further than that. The Secretary-General has asked me to remind the Council that, in addition to the terms of the Sochi Final statement itself, an explicit UN-Russian understanding was made during the Vienna consultations, which took place just before the UN attended Sochi – namely that I as Special Envoy would be free to draw not only on names emanating from Sochi but also on other names, including of Syrians who did not attend Sochi, if necessary to form a balanced and credible list.
8.      And let me recall also that Security Council resolution 2254 anyway mandates the United Nations to convene parties in the political process, and tasks the Geneva talks to set a schedule and process for drafting a new constitution.
9.      The Middle Third list was developed very carefully, believe me, by the United Nations. We received inputs, listened to many – including the guarantors of course, and also others. Above all, we also did our own careful homework.
10.  We sought out credible and neutral Syrian experts – including people who have played a role in previous constitution-making process – who could bridge build between the sides, and whom the two sides could constructively work with. We looked for respected civil society representatives, independents and other Syrians of standing – individuals who could somehow represent the many Syrians who are not political affiliates but still deserve a stake in their future – as in any other constitutional process.
11.  Of course, we do know that all Syrians, like all of us, have some political opinions or leanings – that is natural. But we sought a fair balance between those leanings, so that no political side could dominate the committee –  this is a key part of what we consider the “credibility and legitimacy” of the list.
12.  We ensured adequate representation of different ethnic, religious and regional backgrounds – as well as a balance between those living inside Syria and the millions of Syrians for the moment living outside their country due to the conflict.
13.  And finally, with the full support of the Secretary-General and as part of our commitment to give effect to Security Council resolutions on women, peace and security, we insisted that a minimum of 30% of the constitutional committee should be women, and this meant bringing many qualified and expert women, of all backgrounds, into the Middle Third.  Indeed, the proposed Middle Third is almost half women. 
14.  That is what has guided the UN effort to facilitate the Middle Third, and to revise it into a new list, as it has already done.
15.  I have also carefully facilitated the development, as 2254 and Sochi both say that I should, on a logical basis, of some basic aspects of process and rules of procedure that could enable the constitutional committee to work.
16.  From the three lists – government, opposition, and middle third – it would be possible to identify a smaller group – 15 from each – to form a drafting body of the constitutional committee. 
17.  The constitutional committee could be mandated to draft for popular approval a constitutional reform, as a contribution to the political settlement in Syria leading to a new political structure, giving effect to the Sochi Final Statement of 30 January 2018, within the context of the Geneva process to implement Security Council resolution 2254. Such a constitutional reform could aim to embody in the constitution and constitutional practices of Syria the letter and spirit of the 12 Principles developed in Geneva, with a lot of hard work, and endorsed in Sochi, which offer the people of Syria a vision of a future that can be shared by all. 
18.  The constitutional committee could work in Geneva with impartial Syrian chairmanship acceptable to all components and supported by UN facilitation, and with appropriate decision-making arrangements. 
19.  These arrangements should all take place consistent with respect for the sovereignty, unity, independence and territorial integrity of Syria, and with UN facilitation to enable the Syrians themselves to engage each other and to independently and democratically determine their own future with dignity.
20.  Clearly, the key parties are the Syrian parties, and equally, the prospect of a constitutional committee being effective does rest also on strong support from key countries. These will be further engaged by us in the coming few weeks.
21.  So, let me start with the Government of Syria. Deputy Prime Minister and Foreign Minister Moualem met the Secretary-General during the General Assembly – I also attended the meeting. 
22.  The Foreign Minister on that occasion did strongly cast doubt on the Sochi statement and its outcome, indicating that the Government had very different understandings about those matters. He called for a fundamental reassessment of the work that has been done to date on the Middle Third list and rules of procedure, and on the UN facilitation role.
23.  For his part, the Secretary-General reiterated the Sochi statement and outcome and the mandate of the Security Council, and offered to have me explain the work that has been done on that basis in much more detail. He appealed to the Foreign Minister for the Government to work in partnership with the UN.
24.  For their part, two of the Astana guarantors – Russia and Iran – have also called the Middle Third list into significant question – indicating that it does not meet the requirements of the Government, notwithstanding the extensive consultations and the Sochi understandings. They have at the same time indicated that they continue to engage the Government of Syria on the matters. Senior Russian officials will indeed be in Damascus in the coming days. 
25.  Turkey, which had initially felt that our list could benefit from revision, has indicated lately its full understanding of the logic and composition of the list now on the table.  
26.  For its part, the Syrian Negotiations Committee – “the opposition” – confirmed to the Secretary-General during the General Assembly their readiness to move ahead on the basis of the broad package on the table. The opposition met at the beginning of this week in Riyadh, and most of their nominees for the constitutional committee are at present, while we are talking, sitting together in internal consultations to prepare for their work.
27.  The Small Group of countries – Egypt, France, Germany, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, the United Kingdom and the United States – have all urged that the United Nations convene the constitutional committee without delay. Similar messages came during the last few days from a large number of European and Arab Foreign Ministers with whom I met during the General Assembly.
Querido Señor Presidente,
28.  I wish to inform the Security Council that the Government of Syria has invited me to Damascus next week. This is a follow-up to the meeting with the Secretary-General during the General Assembly. I plan to engage them on the work that has been done on the Constitutional Committee. I will of course be ready, if the Council so wishes, to report back to it after my visit on whether these direct consultations have produced, as we hope, the approval and agreement on a credible and inclusive third list.
29.  I also intend before the end of the month to invite the Astana guarantors for consultations with me in Geneva, and also to engage the Small Group. That would, in my view, be the last opportunity for putting finishing touches on the preparations for convening a constitutional committee.
30.  I would hope then to be in a position to issue invitations to convene the constitutional committee hopefully during November. I offer no prediction whether  this is possible be possible. What I do know is that after nine months of preparations, it is important to launch a credible constitutional committee and that whatever transpires, I would like to come back and brief you  in November on where we stand.
31.  Let me remind all of us: without steps on a safe, calm and neutral environment, the work of a constitutional committee will not end up being very meaningful. We all know that. But first thing first: the constitutional committee. On this front, despite our best efforts regarding steps on safe, calm and neutral environment, we have seen very few concrete outcomes during 2018. I hope we will see more in the coming months. For instance, the Working Group on the release of detainees and abductees, the handover of bodies and the identification of missing people met again last week in Tehran -- but we keep urging for the first tangible results. Many, many people in Syria are waiting for that.
32.  Let’s look now at the big picture for a moment and then we go back to the constitutional committee. A catastrophe has so far been averted in Idlib, and the Russian-Turkish memorandum of understanding appears to be being implemented. Major strides have been taken in defeating terrorism and this should continue to be a priority. ISIL’s territorial base has largely been erased – though it does remain dangerous. The de facto map of Syria is for the moment relatively stable, but it must not become a de facto soft partition, nor a theatre for new international confrontations. There must therefore be a political path forward. President Putin and President Erdogan said that the Idlib deal offered a window for the constitutional committee to be established and the political process to go ahead. The European Union will host for instance a third Brussels Conference in March 2019 – we know that its decisions will depend on a credible political process. 
33.  The United Nations has done all that it can, and frankly more, to find a way to convene a credible and balanced constitutional committee. We are ready to do more and in an accelerated way during the forthcoming month, taking advantage of the Idlib window of opportunity, but we are not ready to convene a committee that is not credible and balanced.
34.  In that regard, having consulted the Secretary-General, let me also give you some heads up - if I may: I will myself be moving on as of the last week of November. I have had the honor to serve for four years and four months as Special Envoy. I have for some time been discussing with the Secretary-General my desire for purely personal reasons to move on. I have deeply appreciated his constant support and wise counsel on this matter. 
35.  But I will definitely not say goodbyes or engage in reflections today. A month can be a century in politics. We still have a very intense and hopefully fruitful month ahead. I am not laying down the charge until the last hour of the last day of my mandate. In fact, the Secretary-General has instructed me that my last month of service should be used to actively verify whether the UN is in a position or not to convene a credible and balanced constitutional committee and report to the Security Council accordingly. I plan to do so with clarity and frankness, and count on the support of the Security Council and all Syrian counterparts to do so.  
36.  So, let me summarise some bottom lines of my message, which has been long:
1) The Idlib MOU provides a unique window of opportunity for launching a credible and inclusive constitutional committee. We must take advantage of it. This is and remains our aim. And our assessment is that, if there is a political will, there is no reason for the constitutional committee not to convene in November, 10 months after the Sochi declaration;
2) The main reason so far for the delay in convening in Geneva the first session of a credible and inclusive constitutional committee, is the difficulties that the Government finds to accept the current Third list of participants prepared by the UN, as per the Sochi declaration and resolution 2254;
3) I plan to discuss this pending issue during my forthcoming mission to Damascus, and report back to the Secretary-General and the Security Council thereafter on the outcome; 
4) Since my personal plan – purely personal, believe me – in consultation with the Secretary-General, has always been to end my mission for purely personal reasons in the last week of November 2018, which means 4 years and 4 months after the beginning of this mission, my intention, and as per the Secretary-General’s instructions, is to dedicate this crucial last month to actively verify once for all the feasibility of the implementation of a credible and inclusive constitutional committee, and hence also the implementation of the Sochi declaration.
5) I will therefore report in November to the Secretary-General and the Security Council on the status of the implementation of the constitutional committee in order to allow the Secretary-General and the Security Council to draw their own conclusions so that my own successor will be able to start from a clean ground his or her mission.
Thank you.

Follow me on Twitter @NabilAbiSaab


  1. Thank you for sharing

  2. Nội dung bài viết thật tuyệt vời. Mình cũng muốn giới thiệu về một Công ty dịch thuật uy tín - Công ty dịch thuật miền trung - MIDtrans trụ sở chính chính tại địa chỉ 02 Hoàng Diệu, TP Đồng Hới, tỉnh Quảng Bình có Giấy phép kinh doanh số 3101023866 cấp ngày 9/12/2016 là đơn vị chuyên cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật, phiên dịch dành các cá nhân. Hệ thống thương hiệu và các Công ty dịch thuật con trực thuộc: dịch thuật đà nẵng - dịch thuật miền trung tại địa 54/27 Đinh Tiên Hoàng, Quận Hải Châu, TP Đà Nẵng là địa chỉ chuyên cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp tại Đà Nẵng và các khu vực lân cận ; dịch thuật tiếng đức tại sài gòn địa chỉ 47 Điện Biên Phủ, Phường Đakao, Quận 1 TP HCM, dịch thuật nha trang, khánh hòa : địa 101 Trần Hưng Đạo, TP Nha Trang là nhà cung ứng dịch vụ dịch thuật uy tín hàng đầu tại Khánh Hòa; Công ty dịch thuật Viettrans và dịc vụ ben tre translation: dịch vụ dịch thuật tại Bến Tre cho người nước ngoài có nhu cầu, giao diện tiếng Anh dễ sử dụng; dịch thuật tiếng nga tại sài gòn: nhà cung ứng dịch vụ dịch vụ dịch thuật phiên dịch hàng đầu tại TP Hồ Chí Minh; công ty dịch thuật đà nẵng midtrans : Địa chỉ 54 Đinh Tiên Hoàng, Quận Hải Châu, TP Đà Nẵng chuyên cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật công chứng, dịch thuật đa ngôn ngữ, đa chuyên ngành tại Đà Nẵng; Viettrans 43 Điện Biên Phủ, Quận 1 Sài Gòn: chuyên cung cấp dịch vụ dịch thuật đa chuyên ngành toàn quốc; Công ty dịch thuật Hà Nội MIDtrans chuyên cung cấp dịch vụ Viettravel - vietnamese tourist information and travel tips tại 46 Trần Cao Vân, TP Huế chuyên trang về thông tin du lịch và các tour đặc sắc tại Việt Nam, y dược (bao gồm bệnh lý), xây dựng (kiến trúc), hóa chất, thủy nhiệt điện, ngân hàng, tài chính, kế toán. Các dự án đã triển khai của Công ty dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp MIDtrans đều được Khách hàng đánh giá cao và đạt được sự tín nhiệm về chất lượng biên phiên dịch. Đó là kết quả của một hệ thống quản lý chất lượng dịch thuật chuyên nghiệp, những tâm huyết và kinh nghiệm biên phiên dịch nhiều năm của đội ngũ dịch giả của chúng tôi. Hotline: 0947688883. email: . Các bạn ghé thăm site ủng hộ nhé.

  3. Hi there! I know where you can get an opportunity to spend your free time as you like without being obliged to write an essay paper. This writing service never delays the performance of the work!

  4. It is really a relevant and useful post. Excellent way of presentation. It is clear and understanding one. Thanks for sharing. Best Essay Writing Service

  5. Thanks for writing this useful article keep writing you are a great author thanks a lot.If you want to get management assignment help then consult with us we are offering Online Management Assignment Help in Australia.
    Management Assignment Help

  6. Amazing blog with inspiring contents. Thanks a lot for sharing this!! Many times students are tensed for their projects and assignments, so at that time they can take assignment help to complete it on time. There are experts available online who prepare the perfect assignment for you. visit my website for more info.

  7. Assignment writing can be a lonely task and exhaust you tremendously. Hence, students who require immediate assignment help UK usually turn to British Assignment Writing service. This forum has an exceptional set of academic writers recruited in its writing and research department. Moreover, it is significantly cheap and affordable.

  8. Like every other McAfee product, you can easily download the trial version of McAfee LiveSafe antivirus. The trial version of McAfee antivirus is available on its official website that goes by the URL mcafee activate. Although, McAfee LiveSafe is a globally trusted security product but for making sure it is recommended to download the trial version of every security product before purchasing or renewing your security subscription. Visit௹☞ telstra bigpondPlumbers Near account

  9. wigs
    WigNice is an online store speiclaized in wigs business, featuring human hair wigs and hair extensions for women. WigNice promises the hair is 100% human hair and high-qaulity products, low factory price, best customer services. Come to WigNice to get your nice wigs!

  10. Get the best Accounting Assignment Help by experts at We Offer exceptional Accounting Assignment Help and writing services at the best price.

    Accounting Assignment Help

  11. Looking for Airlines help with changing or canceling a flight, getting a refund, managing your miles, or something else? We're here to assist. call +1 888-971-3793
    Airlines Support Number

  12. Looking for Mass Communication Assignment Help? Visit NeedAssignmentHelp we are providing top quality assignment help in AUS, UK, USA. 100 % Trusted & Secure. On-time Delivery And Affordable Price.
    Mass Communication Assignment Help

  13. If you are in need for online writing assistance for an intricate thesis topic, then avail prime assignment writing service in Australia and save your time to relax and do your studies properly. Their taxation assignment help has earned huge popularity among both domestic and international students. You can contact GoAssignmentHelp now to buy assignments online. Leave your tensions and enjoy your free time.

  14. Looking for top quality Human Resource Management Assignment Help to impress your professors? Most students find it challenging. NeedAssignmentHelp Having expert writers to help you on your Human Resource Management Assignment.

    Human Resource Management Assignment Help

  15. Geneva is always know for the official works. Geneva is specially know for UN and its work. I know about this place from SEO services

  16. Welcome to, home of the premium High Class Escorts in Bangalore area. Our Bangalore escorts are the supreme Bangalore has to offer and will provide an unforgettable Bangalore Escort experience!

    Models Escorts in Bangalore | Top Bangalore Escorts | VIP Escorts in Bangalore | Pune Escorts Models | Escorts in Pune | Elite Escort Service in Bangalore | VVIP Pune escorts | High Profile Bangalore Escorts | Bangalore High Profile Escorts | Elite Escorts in Pune | Bangalore High Class Escorts

  17. Excellent thread, I have to thank for this. It helps me a lot to enhance my knowledge. I really like the way the writer presented his views.
    thermal engineering assignment help
    engineering assignment help
    electrical engineering assignment help

  18. Thanks for sharing this post, I am David Martin, a professional academic content writer expert based in Australia and working for NeedAssignmentHelp. We support students 24/7 and help you scoring A+ Grades in assignments.
    Visit my website - Project Management Assignment Help

  19. We do your online class as we offer quality online class help and we are best if you’re searching to Pay Someone To Take My Class Online For Me or pay someone to do my online class!

  20. What a lovely and interesting blog. I have read many blogs on the internet but I like your post the most. Thank you for sharing it to our readers.

    Vietnam Shore Excursions | Phong Nha Pioneer Travel

  21. Nice post, Thanks for information about this topic, keep posting!

  22. Nice details and article, it will really helpful for me

  23. Very nice Details, Keep posting, will happy to see your next post soon.

  24. Online education writing services companies have come up with Online Education Assignment Help for education and teaching studies students in order for them to score straight A’s in their custom education research paper services.

  25. Very nice article, Keep posting, love from India and best wishes.

    best camera smartphone in india

  26. im writing this comment because I like the article, best wishes

    rajasthan tour package from mumbai

  27. Very impressive article, many things i have learned. thanks for sharing nice information.

    rajasthan tour package from mumbai

  28. Very impressive article, I like the art of writing, keep posting.

    shimla manali tour

  29. I am glad to see this post. Mr. Staffan De Mistura, you are a beautiful human being. Thanks for sharing. write my assignment cheap uk

  30. Putlocker may be a seamless portal for television, series, movies, songs, etc. for free. it's not mainly for any film or language, from Hollywood to Bollywood, one can have access to each possible movie. In fact, unlike other portals who operate completely illegally, Putlocker has an official site named that a broad base of individuals is mad.

    For the official content recorded, over 1.6 million people worldwide made access to it portal on a per-day basis. because of the piracy issues, it faced a report by motion picture Association of America, which led to its pack up by the united kingdom court Order. it had been considered together of the highest 250 sites visited by the people worldwide. Although, thanks to its massive fan base, Putlockers remains operated under different proxy websites.